This question has been debated for many years and I’ll try my hardest to not offend either side of the debate! The easiest answer is that it all depends on what someone means when they use these terms. Psychotherapy is a form of counselling that uses the psychodynamic approach. Psychodynamic therapy, amongst other things, has an emphasis on 1) childhood experience, 2) the unconscious, and 3) transference.
- A person’s childhood is seen as greatly impacting their adult life, so psychotherapists look at how themes from childhood are replayed in the present.
- A psychotherapist also tries to help a client understand things that were previously hidden to them (in the unconscious).
- Transference happens when a client reacts to their therapist as if they were a person in their past. A psychotherapist will look for this and use it to help the client.
There are specific training programs for psychotherapists, so some who use the title ‘psychotherapist’, are referring to both their training and their psychodynamic approach.
However, there are also counsellors who have not done specific psychotherapy training but who still use a psychodynamic approach when counselling. They usually study psychodynamics as part of their general counselling training. They might also have received personal psychotherapy and done Continued Professional Development (CPD) in it. Some of these counsellors might only use a psychodynamic approach, whilst others only use psychodynamics when it best suits their client, and at other times use different counselling approaches, such as Person Centred Counselling.
Sometimes psychotherapists complain that some counsellors call themselves psychotherapists without having had enough specific psychotherapy training. In other instances, there are counsellors who do not like the psychodynamic approach and therefore don’t want to be called psychotherapists.
So, when I hear the term ‘counselling’ I tend to think of counselling in quite general terms, but when I hear ‘psychotherapy’ I think of a specific psychodynamic approach. But I find it helpful to ask the person what they mean by these terms, to avoid any confusion.
By Duncan Forbes